Reviews > Published on November 5th, 2014

Bookshots: 'Treat Us Like Dogs and We Will Become Wolves' by Carolyn Chute

Bookshots: Pumping new life into the corpse of the book review


Treat Us Like Dogs and We Will Become Wolves

Who wrote it?

Perhaps best known for her first novel, The Beans of Egypt Maine (which was made into a movie), Carolyn Chute is an author and political activist known for her passionate defense of the right to bear arms set out in the 2nd Amendment to the Constitution.

Plot in a Box:

Based on a number of provocative phone calls to the local paper alleging everything from child abuse to child slavery to polygamy to a possible Waco scenario complete with stockpiles of guns, Ivy Morelli, feature reporter, is sent to meet a reclusive group known as “the Settlement”, or sometimes “the Home School”, to investigate. What she finds is not what she expects —or what we expect. The charismatic leader of the group pulls her in and has a way with females that most men just dream about. But is he everything he seems? 

Phone calls to the local paper, allege everything from child abuse to child slavery to polygamy to a possible Waco scenario complete with stockpiles of guns...

Invent a new title for this book:

I would call it: Do They Have Guns or Not?

Read this if you liked:

Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein

Meet the book’s lead:

The focus of the book is Guillame “Gordon” St Onge, a big bear of a Maine backwoodsman and dyed in the wool isolationist with a messianic quality, often overpowered by the “family” he’s created in rural Maine.

Said lead would be portrayed in a movie by:

A 30-something Gérard Depardieu in his charismatic prime with a Maine accent.

Setting: would you want to live there?

The story is set in southern Maine with no discernible major cities nearby; it’s an idyllic setting and sounds very beautiful. I can picture it without effort and yes, would happily live there.

What was your favorite sentence?

And what are those at the other end of the bed sticking up under the blanket? He can’t remember exactly the words. Hooves? Handles? Claws?

The Verdict:

This is an odd book, make no bones about it. It is written as a series of excerpts from people’s lives and memories, interspersed with proclamations from Mammon, the Media and aliens (who aren’t) labeled just “The Greys”, as in the popular visitor from another planet. Each section is set out with it’s own icon to help distinguish between the various voices.

This is a heavily political book based on Chute’s leanings toward the fringe militias and the message is clear: America is ruled by the rich and anyone who thinks otherwise is going to get stepped on and hard. I guess it portrays the sort of community society a lot of people aspire to but which often goes wrong, a la Waco, the Heaven’s Gate tragedy or Jim Jones’s poisoned Kool-aid in Guyana: a society where individuals matter and want to be able to rule themselves. Something that organized society tends to frown on.

I spent a great deal of the book wondering what the hell was going on and, although I liked the Settlement people, it felt like they were just tempting fate — just asking for trouble. This is a follow-on from Chute’s 2008, 2,000 page mega-book The School on Heart’s Content Road, but it explores the same themes of a group of outsiders and the way outsiders view and deal with them.

While I’m not sure I can recommend this book, it’s a lot shorter than the previous version. Still, it’s worth a look if you’re trying to understand what makes people set themselves aside from the mainstream and try to carve out a niche for the way they want to live.

About the author

Dean Fetzer is originally from a small town in eastern Colorado, but has lived in London, England, for 21 years now. On reaching London, he worked as a graphic designer and web consultant before starting a pub review website in the late 90’s.

His current book series, The Jaared Sen Quartet is set in near-future London, but also encompasses historical elements, reflecting his fascination with missing artifacts and conspiracy theories.

Dean left pub reviews behind in 2011 to concentrate on his writing and to set up a new company offering publishing services to authors, poets and artists as well as blogging and writing book reviews on his website at He lives in east London with his wife and two cats and dreams (often) of a house in France.

Similar Reviews

Explore other reviews from across the blog.

Reedsy | Editors with Marker (Marketplace Editors)| 2024-05

Submitting your manuscript?

Professional editors help your manuscript stand out for the right reasons.

Reedsy Marketplace UI

1 million authors trust the professionals on Reedsy. Come meet them.

Enter your email or get started with a social account: