Ultimate Spider-Man: The Hero We Need (Though Might Not Want)


There was much to be said when it was revealed that the Ultimate Universe's Spider-Man (Peter Parker) was going to be killed off. For many, Ultimate Spider-Man was the Spider-Man book that hooked a new generation of readers, as the Ultimate line was released to capitalize on those who came to the franchise because of the movies. So how do you smoothly ease someone into the rich history of a character who has been around since 1962? The short answer is you don't even try. Thus, the Ultimate line was created - fresh takes on old characters that people could jump into without having to worry about years of backstory.

Despite not being around for long, Ultimate Spider-Man developed an avid following, so there was much sadness over his death. Along with the grieving, an even more powerful emotion started rising from the fans - anger. Readers were enraged at the fact that it wasn't necessarily Spider-Man who was being killed off, but Peter Parker, as the title was set to continue with someone new under the mask. Fans were willing to embrace an already established cast member, but nobody was expecting a young half-African-American, half-Hispanic kid named Miles Morales. Fans took to the message boards asking, "How could Marvel resort to such stunt casting? Spider-Man can't be black!" For many it was pandering to the lowest degree, as news of Batwing (an African-American Batman character) was also released around the same time by DC Comics.

I must admit that even I was skeptical when Miles was revealed as the new Spider-Man. It seemed like nothing more than a flimsy excuse to try and appeal to not just one, but two minority groups for the sake of the almighty dollar. It's not like Marvel hasn't already done its fair share of stunt casting in the past, though typically it's been done to try and appeal to a female audience (though titillation for men could easily be claimed as well). The Hulk got a female equivalent by way of She-Hulk. If you need a female version of Wolverine try X-23. Even Spider-Man, for that matter, has Spider-Woman. I could go on, but you get the picture. Marvel's even tried the tactic on non-heroes, as the recent craze has been to take popular villains and change them into or introduce their female counterpart (Lady Bullseye and Loki's run as a woman say hello). So while Marvel hasn't generally shaken up the status quo by completely changing the race of a character - Nick Fury is the only one that comes to mind right away - you couldn't look at Marvel's past and not think there was a chance that this was exactly what they were doing here. Plus, having Ultimate Spider-Man's writer - Brian Michael Bendis - come out and say, "Even though there's some amazing African-American and minority characters bouncing around in all the superhero universes, it's still crazy lopsided," pretty-much sealed the deal.

As the release date for the second volume of Ultimate Spider-Man came closer, I started reading more about the rationale behind the decision. Sure, part of it was that they wanted to give minority readers a character to call their own, but Bendis insisted that there was also a story to tell; a story that just happened to tie in with one of my favorite television shows, Community. After it was announced that the Spider-Man movie franchise was being rebooted with a new cast, speculation arose regarding who would play the titular role of Peter Parker. Community actor Donald Glover stepped up and threw his name into the mix, and even started Twitter and Facebook campaigns to promote himself. As a nod to the Spider-Man run, Glover's character was even seen wearing Spider-Man pajamas at the beginning of the second season's premiere. People laughed at the notion, thinking the whole thing was a stunt just to get his name thrown around, but it raised some interesting debates and questions. The chief one being, why can't Spider-Man be something other than Caucasian? Are white people the only ones going out there and being heroes on a daily basis? In real life there's a vast rainbow of people with heroic professions such as firefighters, police officers, and those in the Armed Forces. Brian Michael Bendis saw the campaign and the Community premiere and thought to himself, that would be a book he'd not only like to read, but write as well.

I have a tendency to give most any book a shot, and while I always hope to find a gem, reading a train wreck is equally as thrilling at times (though my wallet cries every time I do). We tend to devote our time to things that we enjoy, but for every Oscar winning flick we say is astounding there's some popcorn, B-movie drivel that we love just as much. So I picked up the first issue, went home, and put it at the very bottom of my stack. I don't know how you read your comics, but I always start with the best and work towards what I think will be the worst. Imagine my surprise when I finally got to it, finished it, and thought, "That wasn't half-bad." In fact, I thought the first issue of Ultimate Spider-Man was pretty damn good. I picked up the second issue a month later and this time wedged it somewhere in the middle of my pile, as I was anxious to read it, but books I'd been reading longer came first (seniority has to have its place somewhere). By the time the third issue came around, it wasn't a series I had a passing interest in or one I'd get to after my old favorites were finished, it was the book that went straight to the top of the pile. Before long it became my number one read. I had to know what came next.

Four issues into the series' run and, frankly, it's a book that shouldn't be as good as it is. I wouldn't go so far as to say it's pandering, but you can't read it and not think that Bendis is trying to cram in every possible race, sex, and pant size that he can. Instead of pleasing just two minoritiy groups, he wants everyone to feel welcomed. Miles Morales is a smart, skinny, half-African-American and half-Hispanic child. Miles' best friend Ganke is an intelligent, geeky and chunky Asian boy. Miles' mom is a smoking hot Latina, his father an ex-criminal who has turned his life around, and his uncle is a thief that used to run with his father. You almost expect that when/if the time ever comes, Miles' crush is going to be a little white girl and her best friend someone who comes out as being gay. The book shouldn't work because of these characters, and yet it's the reason I keep flipping the pages month after month. A Spider-Man book where the main character hasn't caught a purse thief, let alone fought a villain? Blasphemy!

Though the series is chatty, it's filled with wonderful dialogue that you want to linger in your head. You want to read it out loud just so your ears can hear the words being brought to life. As you make your way through the book, you start to really get the bigger picture.  Ultimate is no longer the "black Spider-Man" book, but rather a story about a young boy trying to decide why he's so special. Ultimate Spider-Man is about the human soul, the angel and the devil on each shoulder egging us on, and ultimately choosing to do what's right and standing up to be a hero.

It was one such character-driven and dialogue-heavy moment that won me over in the end - a modern day interpretation of the old Spider-Man motto, "With great power comes great responsibility." During the scene, Miles is sat down by his dad in the park, where he goes into great length about how he and his brother used to commit crimes because they saw no other way out of the predicament that life had handed to them, but that he eventually saw there was a brighter side to life. That things could be changed and that, despite his flawed past, he could reform and become someone a son could be proud of:

"I'm not making excuses for myself...I'm telling you that I paid for my mistakes and I've spent every single day of my life trying not to repeat them. There's good and bad in everyone. Anyone can be bad, anyone. It's easy. It's the easiest thing. But to stay focused. To live a good life...it's the hardest damn thing. Do you understand?"

It was this moment that sealed the deal for me. It was the panel that made me put the third and fourth issues at the top of my pile so that they could be devoured and savored before anything else. It doesn't quite have the ring of the old Uncle Ben saying, but it sets the tone for the series wonderfully. It's easy to do bad things to people, but to live life morally and do what's right despite whatever gets thrown at you...that's what a real hero is in the end.

The book also succeeds because Miles Morales isn't just a Peter Parker clone, which is what some people were worried about. Why kill Peter Parker if you're going to give us someone just like him, only a different race? Because Peter Parker has been pretty consistent throughout all the various mediums he's appeared in. He often starts out somewhat cocky, wanting to use his powers to get that edge (his wrestling career), but then, through a twist of fate, someone suffers because he wasn't there and thus a hero is born. Ultimate Spider-Man's Miles couldn't be more different, as his struggle hasn't been about whether to use his powers and for what purpose. Rather, he suffers from a type of "survivor's guilt," and wonders why he has been given this edge. Why did he get lucky and get into the charter school? Why did he receive these superpowers? As I mentioned, Miles hasn't even really fought any villains, and outside of one heroic situation, he's kept his powers pretty contained. Miles' journey so far has been about taking that first step towards doing something spectacular in life, and coming to grips with the powers that have been handed to him. In an ironic twist of fate, Miles' Uncle Ben moment comes by way of Peter Parker himself, as he does battle with Green Goblin. After Peter's death and the news starts making the rounds that New York's hero was a high school student all this time, Miles starts to see that heroes come in all shapes, sizes, and ages. He starts to realize that if he'd made himself known to Spider-Man, had him train and guide him, maybe he would've been able to help during that climatic showdown, and maybe a good kid wouldn't have had to die for doing what was right.

Even in terms of his superpowers, Miles' Spider-Man is different than Peter's in several ways. The covers for Ultimate Spider-Man show Miles shooting webbing, but whether it's an organic web or a synthetic one made in a lab remains to be seen. Miles has the same strength and reflexes as Peter, even the same spider-sense (though he doesn't register what that tingling in his brain is for yet) and wall sticking ability, but the biggest change comes by way of his cloaking ability. He's essentially able to camouflage himself into the background like a chameleon and make himself unseen. It sounds ridiculous and unlike any ability I've ever heard of a spider having, but sure enough Miles' power is grounded in reality, and there are indeed chameleon spiders out there. Another big change is that Miles can use a venom strike, which isn't completely unique since other Spider-Man family members have wielded it before, but it's the first time to the best of my recollection that Spider-Man will have it.

I can be a skeptical man. When it was announced that the new Ultimate Spider-Man was going to be half-African-American and half-Hispanic, it sounded like the end of bad racist joke. As I read up on the decision, the change seemed less like a gimmick and more like an opportunity for the comic industry. There are a number of minority characters within the Marvel universe, and while many of them might have the powers to be a superhero, they often lack the power to be a role model for the group they represent. They're generally second string characters who back up the power players like Captain America, Iron Man, and Thor. With the re-launch of Ultimate Spider-Man, however, we have a hero who isn't just fascinating as a character, but also for what he means to a whole new generation. Because they deserve a hero to call their own. Miles Morales might not be the person behind the mask that everyone else wanted, but now that he's here, we realize he's the hero we've needed for a long time.

Jason Van Horn

Column by Jason Van Horn

Jason has worked as the editorial manager and head writer for a number of sci-fi/fantasy and videogame related sites that were part of the IGN network once upon a time. He currently writes for LitReactor, where he puts his love of comics to good use, and the gaming website MPOGD, where he handles reviews, previews, and interviews for all things multiplayer.

To leave a comment Login with Facebook or create a free account.


Dwayne's picture
Dwayne from Cincinnati, Ohio (suburbs) is reading books that rotate to often to keep this updated December 9, 2011 - 4:02pm

Crap, complete and utter crap. Spider-man is Peter Parker, Peter Parker is Spider-man. You might be able to get an audience with a black Peter Parker, but any attempt to vary from Peter Parker makes about as much sense as casting Lady Gaga as Martin Luther King Jr. in a serious biographical film. Maybe instead of trying cheap stunt rewrites to shoe horn characters into things they think will sell/improve PR maybe someone should write a new interesting mixed race character.
If this character is a well written and well drawn addition who brings something important to the table that is even worse. Because sooner or later he’ll join the ranks of Kyle Rayner and the Super-Man Clone, as a unremembered temporary replacement for the real super-hero. No matter how awesome he is as a comic in real life, he is in 10 years him and the Scarlet Spider are just hanging out waiting to go on a list of “10 Oddest Replacement Heroes” in Wizard.

misskokamon's picture
misskokamon from San Francisco is reading The Moonlit Mind December 9, 2011 - 4:19pm

Actually, this article got me interested. Miles, consider yourself and your chunky asian friend PREORDERED.

Rob's picture
Class Director
Rob from New York City is reading at a fast enough pace it would be cumbersome to update this December 9, 2011 - 4:25pm

Dwayne: Why such a visceral reaction? 

It's not like there are no other Peter Parker/Spider-man comics. This is a story that takes place in an "alternate universe" (if you consider the Ultimates line to be 'alternate'). 

It's sort of interesting that Spider-man is one of the few superheroes that's completely covered from head to toe, so to the fictional people that populate his world, they don't know if he's white, black, Latino or Asian. 

Him being Peter Parker doesn't make any real difference to the other characters in his world (outside of the people who know his indentity/are his family). 

I've been reading the comics, and while I wish they were a little longer (they seem oddly short, like shorter than a normal comic should be), I think it's an interesting story, and I'll happily keep reading. We're kinda at the point know where Spider-man is more of a concept than a specific person. 

Nice piece, Jay. 

Joshua Chaplinsky's picture
Joshua Chaplinsky from New York is reading Library Books December 9, 2011 - 4:56pm

If they had cast Donald Glover in the new Spiderman movie, I might have actually been interested.

aliensoul77's picture
aliensoul77 from a cold distant star is reading the writing on the wall. December 9, 2011 - 6:04pm

I was skeptical at first too until I read it and the Ultimate line is different than the regular run of comics, so haters can still have the whiter spiderman. As for the new movies, I will reserve judgment because I dig Andrew Garfield as an actor and Emma Stone as Gwen is hot.

Dwayne's picture
Dwayne from Cincinnati, Ohio (suburbs) is reading books that rotate to often to keep this updated December 9, 2011 - 11:39pm

@ Rob/Jay - I meant that as "What Marvel is doing here is crap, complete and utter crap." The article is fine. It is Marvel doing something stupid that I have the viseral reaction to. 

In chracter, no not many people would even notice much less care. As an aside if they skip overa few people who've seen the suit shreeded all to heck, heard his voice dozens of times, and/or should know his build from seeing him hundreds of times not notice that'll be even worse. Out out of character sooner or later fans will go back to the orgianl character. After a long enough time the character gets rooted in, when you get away from it At best this is a cheap stunt that will get a few laughs and some peole have some work for a while, whatever. At worst it's a throwing away real art that will be remembered as "the time they had Black Spider-Man!", which is sad.

And Ultimates has been going on for 10 years now, it's got to be on/near equal footing with universe.

Bradley Sands's picture
Bradley Sands from Boston is reading Greil Marcus's The History of Rock 'N' Roll in Ten Songs December 10, 2011 - 4:09am

I don't care about the character's ethnicity. The title just doesn't seem as strong as Ultimate Spider-Man before Peter Parker died.

Mick Cory's picture
Mick Cory from Kentucky is reading everything you have ever posted online and is frankly shocked you have survived this long December 10, 2011 - 7:03am



"... why can't Spider-Man be something other than Caucasian? Are white people the only ones going out there and being heroes on a daily basis? In real life there's a vast rainbow of people with heroic professions such as firefighters, police officers, and those in the Armed Forces."

   Are you kidding me? In the year 2011 this is qualifies as a revelation?

   Color it how you wish, the reaction (from what I would wager is predominately older readers) is dripping with racism. I would think that at nearly twenty two hundred words, the author could have engaged the reality of the situation.

Rob's picture
Class Director
Rob from New York City is reading at a fast enough pace it would be cumbersome to update this December 10, 2011 - 1:43pm

Dwayne, I'm confused by your comments.

First, of course I know your reaction is to what Marvel did and not the article. I never said you were upset with the article.

Second, this is being done for laughs? What's funny about it?

And I'm still waiting to hear a legitimate argument for why this is bad. Your argument so far is: Because.

What's detrimental about a black Spider-man? Who/what does it hurt? And don't say the integrity of the character. One, it's a comic book. Two, Peter Parker is alive and well in the main Marvel universe, the movies, the video games, the cartoons, and every other intellectual property based on Spider-man.

Dwayne's picture
Dwayne from Cincinnati, Ohio (suburbs) is reading books that rotate to often to keep this updated December 16, 2011 - 5:17am

“A few laughs” as interchangeable with "cheap thrills". Maybe that isn't the common usage of the term, if not my mistake.

Nothing is detrimental about a black Spider-Man. Like I said Spider-Man is Peter Parker. Any attempt to vary from that is crap. It isn't related to his replacement being black. I literally made an excrement reference about the return of the Scarlet Spider.


Replacing Peter Parker is detrimental. Why is it bad?

1) Because no matter what story they tell it ends up on a Wizards list of "10 Oddest/Worst Replacements." It hurts the reputation of black characters as being able to hold the role of a serious new super hero. Regardless or the truth/morality of the situation gives it the perception of minority heroes don't sell/only sell if white guy establishes the franchise. There is no good outcome regarding the role of minorities in comics.

2) It confuses young readers who relate to this guy. I'm sure that a few minority children who read comics will be thrilled to see someone who has some similarities as themselves as a hero. Then they'll wonder why he can't be in the main universe, have his own movies, or his own products past a few cheap t-shirts/tie in novels. It alienates them from comics.

3) Junk like this is why you say things like "One, it's a comic book." I'm not saying they can ever be Shakespeare, but it would be nice if they didn't feel the need to have silly just be 100% accepted with no argument.

4) Its bad story telling. You don't put a new king in charge of the Round Table. You put Arthur. You don't come up with a new character in the retelling of legend to replace one you dislike you find a way to fix the things you don't like. And Spider-Man fits the Webster definition of legend. See entry C.


5) Printing this takes up pages that could just be used for something better. Spider-Man has a really great track record of doing everything for breaking ground stuff. I understand that the idea of a guy who has spider powers is a bit silly but that silliness has been used for some very important real world stuff. It was a big part of the early feet-of-clay super-heroes the first steps towards the more believable heroes that are just a given today. By having problems that if not what every teenager has, every teenager has at least seen. It was one of the first to stand up the censorship of the Comic Code by telling one of the first stories about drug use in comics. They could be dealing about stories about criminals who aren’t bad people just desperate in tough times. They could be doing stories about war vets missing a limb. They could be doing stories about trying to get kids who voted for BHO and feel let down and don’t want to go vote for anybody or get involved with anything going on around them. They could be doing stories about the first responders not being invited to 9/11 events or the fall out of the Occupy moment. Heck, they could be doing a story about texting getting someone in a car wreck. Instead of trying to stick with that proud (if absurd) tradition it seems they decided to go with "Let’s see if we can boost sales if we kill him and bring in black kid. No wait a half black/half Latino kid so we get both minorities to but it." I admit they could do all those stories with the new guy but not until AFTER they spend time establishing who he is/others reactions to him.

6) If this Miles Morales is a story that needs told he should get something new, something fresh. He should be allowed to play out his own drama and comedy and what not without 49 years of baggage that older fans bring to the name.

7) It's just rude. In a shared universe when you do something this drastic some other poor guy has to come up behind you and clean up your mess. Either they have to cancel the book or they have to bring back Peter and put Miles on a bus. Or make Miles Spider-something. Hopefully NOT Spider-Boy. So instead of trying to write a awesome story, the new guy is trying to unwrite your story. And the reader has to watch or move on.

8) Mainly this kid needs to stop running around and having this day in the life racial commentary thing so he can go save some people. Spider-Man is a super-hero. The series reads like Emo song lyrics sheet - he wanted to fight crime, but he was too sad. Right now in the story if he went in his room and blew his head off, who would he endanger besides the guy apartment upstairs? Is this hippster Spidy? He was going to fight crime but that was too lame stream?

9) Organic webbing. A young guy running around shooting white stuff out of his body is a just a little too pedo for me.

10) No web shooters. Peter Parker was able to design web shooters. This kid, no so much.

I wouldn't be upset with them for trying to make a few bucks if the company hadn't already made untold millions of this character telling better stories then this. When someone choices the path that made them rich while accomplishing something (telling fairly deep stories) and a cheap stunt that will do who knows what sales wise I’m convinced they shouldn’t go with the one that makes money while telling the story.

John Duncan's picture
John Duncan June 1, 2012 - 8:18am

Fans took to the message boards asking, "How could Marvel resort to such stunt casting? Spider-Man can't be black!" For many it was pandering to the lowest degree, as news of Batwing (an African-American Batman character) was also released around the same time by DC Comics.

Maybe this is nit-picking, but DC's Batwing is not African-American. He is from Congo, a country that is nowhere near the American continent, and is therefore simply "African".

On a related note, can you label all white characters as "European-American" in future stories? It makes about as much sense as labelling black characters "African-American" when neither they nor any of their living ancestors has even been to Africa.