We know that quite often the fantasy is better than the reality in most things. When it comes to stories, the ones that enthrall me follow characters that I could read about constantly, but would not necessarily want in my life. Some characters skip over intriguing and exciting and fall right into the category of "absolutely not" for dating material. A real life version of any of them would be a waking nightmare!
If you have read any of the books on this list, you can probably tell from the character's name alone why I would never consider them a romantic match. If you haven't, allow me to explain.
![]()
1. Dorian Gray — 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' by Oscar Wilde
1. Dorian Gray — 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' by Oscar Wilde
Dorian Gray is vain, thoughtless, fickle, and wildly hedonistic. He drives a woman to suicide and murders a man! He has difficulty taking responsibility for his own choices. Dorian may be super attractive, but that's never enough. Sometimes, that's the problem. If a man's face is too handsome, I'll get tired of looking at it. I'm not saying I'd prefer the face of his frightening portrait, but perhaps you can understand my point.
[amazon 0486278077 inline]
2. The Playwright — 'The Playwright' by Eddie Campbell & Daren White
The thing that makes the unnamed playwright in this comic undateable is that he reminds me too much of myself, or what I could become. His plays are well-received by the public, but he is an outsider. His inaction is the least appealing part about him. After a while, the brooding artist becomes less mysterious and more of a bore. A future with the playwright consists of weekends spent in, self-inflicted torment, and many furrowed brows.
[amazon 1603090568 inline]
![]()
3. Nathaniel P. — 'The Love Affairs of Nathaniel P.' by Adelle Waldman
3. Nathaniel P. — 'The Love Affairs of Nathaniel P.' by Adelle Waldman
Nathaniel P. teeters between typical fellow and jackass throughout The Love Affairs of Nathaniel P. He kind of cares about people, cares about his goals, but not so strongly that he is sympathetic. He does not rise to his potential, so I would not expect him to rise to a romantic partner of equal or superior intelligence. What I see in Nathaniel P. is calculated mediocrity in matters of the heart. Not attractive!
[amazon 1250050456 inline]
![]()
4. Hamlet — 'Hamlet' by William Shakespeare
4. Hamlet — 'Hamlet' by William Shakespeare
Indecisiveness is death to libido, especially when it leads to tragedy, death, and mayhem. Hamlet doesn't have a sense of who he is, or if he even wants "to be." He also drops one of the most famous disses of all time on Ophelia, the woman he supposedly loves. I would not want to suffer her fate. I'm decidedly staying away from the Prince of Denmark.
[amazon 074347712X inline]
![]()
5. Henry Chinaski — Various Bukowski Novels
5. Henry Chinaski — Various Bukowski Novels
Oh, Bukowski, your alter ego is a terror, but I can't look away. Henry Chinaski is constantly drunk and having mostly awkward sexual encounters with woman after woman, all while achieving a little literary success. He's the perfect anti-hero, and also the perfect anti-boyfriend. I've kept up with his antics, but would definitely keep my distance from the character himself.
[amazon 0061177571 inline]
![]()
6. Patrick Bateman — 'American Psycho' by Bret Easton Ellis
6. Patrick Bateman — 'American Psycho' by Bret Easton Ellis
As a rule, I don't date serial killers. Even if the crimes were all in his mind, Bateman is still insane. Not to mention his general lifestyle: an investment banker who dabbles in cocaine, clubbing, and boring conversation. Again, I don't care how attractive he is. I'm not into it. Moving on.
[amazon 0679735771 inline]
![]()
7. Yunior — 'This is How You Lose Her' by Junot Diaz
7. Yunior — 'This is How You Lose Her' by Junot Diaz
Yunior seems to make the same mistakes again and again. Though written well, I grew tired of his antics throughout This Is How You Lose Her very quickly. In the short story "The Cheater's Guide to Love," Yunior's girlfriend finds out he's cheated on her with fifty women! Fifty! That's all I have to say about that.
[amazon 1594631778 inline]
![]()
8. Ignatius J. Reilly — 'A Confederacy of Dunces' by John Kennedy Toole
8. Ignatius J. Reilly — 'A Confederacy of Dunces' by John Kennedy Toole
Ignatius J. Reilly is my ultimate undateable character. He is so entertaining on the page, but it is completely terrifying to think of dating him. I imagine he would smell like hot dogs and ripe B.O. incessantly. He still lives at home but doesn't respect his mother, can't keep a job, and loves to argue. His fashion sense is lacking, and I doubt he would be willing to take any of my kind advice on that matter. Ignatius is perfect reality show material, but keep him away from me.
[amazon 0802130208 inline]
Even though these bachelors are not-so-eligible, their stories are all eligible for reading.
Take a trip down the undateable male character rabbit hole! Which one is your favorite?
About the author
Christine J. Schmidt is a writer originally from New Jersey. After receiving her BFA in Dramatic Writing from SUNY Purchase, she worked at Seattle Repertory Theatre as their artistic literary intern. She recently left Brooklyn, where she was a bookseller and events host at WORD, to reside in Los Angeles. She has previously written for New York Theatre Review, and her plays have been read and produced at theaters in New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Georgia, and Washington. Coffee is her favorite thing.
