Columns > Published on May 31st, 2012

Top 10 YA Books That Should Be Adapted for Film

There seems to be a flaw in the human brain when it comes to film adaptations of books. I say this because movies rarely, if ever, turn out to be better than their literary source material. And yet, every time I finish an amazing novel, I immediately start praying that it will be made into a film. Seriously, brain, what's up with that?

Well, when it comes to love, I guess I can't be rational, and I'm smitten with these books. The idea of getting to experience them again, in a different if inferior way, still ridiculously excites me, so Hollywood, I hope you're paying attention.


'Incarceron' by Catherine Fisher

I'd see this movie for the visuals alone, although the plot is equally as thrilling. For as long as he can remember, 17-year-old Finn has struggled to survive in Incarceron, a vast prison teeming with wild tribes and dangerous criminals. There are no cells, just a limitless, dark expanse. And there are no guards, just the prison itself, which monitors, controls and tortures its inhabitants with an increasingly human sense of cruelty. When Finn comes into possession of a mysterious crystal key, he and his blood brother, Keiro, begin a quest to follow in the footsteps of Sapphique, the only man to have ever escaped from Incarceron. Just as the outside world is a mystery to Finn, Incarceron is a haunting enigma to Claudia, the prison warden's daughter, who dreams of escaping the suffocating structure of society as well as her arranged marriage. Fisher's epic world-building and her knack for heart-stopping action make this book a perfect match for the film genre, and I'm not the only one who thinks so. Taylor Lautner, originally slated to star in the movie, apparently dropped out, which is good news for fans of the book (because Finn deserves better) but bad news for production of the movie, which sadly might never happen.

[amazon 0142418528 inline]


'The Knife of Never Letting Go' by Patrick Ness

If you're tired of hearing about the greatness of this book, then you obviously haven't read it yet. Seriously! Read it! Immediately! If you need a synopsis, check out my YA Primer, but the bottom line is that this book- the entire trilogy, actually-- is amazing, and the film adaptation might blow The Hunger Games totally out of the water. The story is so creative, so deeply compelling, that I initially feared Hollywood would flatten it into mediocrity. But now that we know Charlie Kaufman is adapting the script, I'm totally frothing at the mouth with anticipation over seeing my beloved Todd fight the awesomely evil Mayor Prentiss, mysterious aliens and his own inner demons on the silver screen.

[amazon 0763645761 inline]


'Graceling' by Kristin Cashore

Sure, Katniss Everdeen was a marked improvement over the lame-o Bella Swan, but Katsa, the heroine of Graceling, is far and above the most badass heroine in YA literature. She's graced (the fantasy version of a mutant power) with the ability to kill, which means she's the most fearsome warrior in all seven kingdoms of Cashore's gorgeously crafted world. Unfortunately, she's controlled by a totally creepy and insane king, but in between assassination assignments, Katsa fights for justice and peace with the help of a secret council. Not only would the battle scenes be jaw-dropping on film, the vividly colorful characters are itching to be inhabited by skilled actors, and the romance between Katsa and the charming but deadly Prince Po would threaten to melt every piece of underwear in the theater.

[amazon 0547258305 inline]


'Beauty Queens' by Libba Bray

I have no doubt that this book would make a ridiculously entertaining movie, but first I have to find someone brave enough to pitch it to a room of Hollywood executives. I can picture it now: "So, the story begins when a plane carrying a group of beauty pageant contestants crash lands onto a deserted island. No, it's not like Lost. Because, see, the beauty queens are actually pawns in an arms conspiracy planned by slightly fictionalized versions of Sarah Palin and Kim Jong-Il, and-- no, I'm serious, this is what the book is about-- and the girls realize they can't just rely on their pageant skills if they want to survive, although beauty tips do come in handy. Oh also, there's pirates." On second thought, how could Hollywood execs NOT go for that?

[amazon 0439895979 inline]


'The Jessica Darling Series' by Megan McCafferty

Although there will never be another John Hughes, I feel like I've been waiting 20 years for someone to carry on his legacy. This generation needs its own Samantha Baker, Duckie and John Bender, and Megan McCafferty is ready to give it to them. In Sloppy Firsts, the beginning of the series, we meet Jessica, an intelligent, self-absorbed angsty teenager with a razor-sharp wit who wants to get the hell out of Pineville, NJ. Over the course of five books, Jessica makes a billion mistakes, fixes some of them, falls in love with a sex god named Marcus Flutie, makes some of the same mistakes again, and somehow maybe kinda becomes an adult. I always try to avoid reading these books in public, because they make me laugh in a highly indecent manner, so it would be a relief to guffaw along with a theatrical audience so I seem less like a crazy person. Jessica is wonderfully flawed, and I have the feeling that if Hollywood gave her a shot, she would easily secure her place in the annals of teen cinema, right between the Heathers (who would maintain a safe distance) and Lloyd Dobler (who would totally crush on her).

[amazon 0609807900 inline]


'Daughter of Smoke and Bone' by Laini Taylor

There are certain authors who I suspect of using magic, and Laini Taylor is one of them. How else do you explain the potent beauty of her prose and the fanciful characters who dance across her pages? Even though film has the advantage of moving images, it still might be tough to compete with the magnificent descriptions of Prague, the city where a blue-haired girl named Karou lives, and the other parts of the world she visits to collect teeth for Brimstone, the crochety demon who raised her. Still, I'd love to see someone try, because this stunning story of wishes, angel and demon warfare, and past lives seems like it might burst from its book binding any minute, and perhaps the big screen might be strong enough to handle it.

[amazon 0316134023 inline]


'The Apothecary' by Maile Meloy

Set in 1952, The Apothecary follows the dashing adventures of Janie Scott, who has recently moved to London after her filmmaking parents were blacklisted in Hollywood. Intrigued by classmate and wannabe spy Benjamin Burrows, Janie suddenly finds herself at the center of an international conspiracy involving atom bombs, invisibility elixirs and a charming pickpocket named Pip. This old fashioned romp is the stuff of my childhood dreams, and it would make a grandly charming film in the vein of Hugo, the kind of movie that will mesmerize adults and kids alike.

[amazon 039925627X inline]


'Inside the Shadow City' by Kirsten Miller

It might not be possible to make this film, since I'm pretty sure no one alive is cool enough to play Kiki Strike, the tiny, white-haired teenage leader of an intrepid band of girls known as The Irregulars. Kiki is a martial arts expert, a master of disguise and happens to be allergic to everything except for cafe au lait. In the first book of what I fear is a short-lived series (third book, where are you?), Kiki befriends Ananka Fishbein, who goes from average girl to brave explorer when she's taken into the Shadow City, a series of tunnels underneath Manhattan. Each marvelous caper ends with an important Irregular lesson, like how to detect if someone is lying or how to plan the best escape route, and it's the kind of material that an inventive director (say, Edgar Wright) would have a field day adapting.

[amazon 1599900920 inline]


'The Scorpio Races' by Maggie Stiefvater

This book has some serious Oscar potential, you guys. And not just because it has horses in it. In fact, this ain't no Sea Biscuit. These horses, known as Capall Uisce, live in the ocean and come out once a year on the beaches of Thisby to hunt for food. And occasionally kill humans. In turn, some brave (or stupid, depending on how you look at it) humans trap the horses and train them to compete in the Scorpio Races, a wild and deadly competition. The spirited, downright stubborn Puck Connelly enters the race because she needs the money to save her family's home, while strong and silent Sean Kendrick races because it's in his blood. It's a violent, epic tale of tradition, passion and family, and I predict that theater audiences will alternate between frenzied fist pumping and crying into their popcorn.

[amazon 054522490X inline]


'Divergent' by Veronica Roth

I raved about this dystopian tour de force in my YA Primer, and I can't wait to see Beatrice Prior kick some serious ass on the big screen. This story is begging for a movie (and it better be R-rated), from the numerous speeding train jumps to the punk rock Dauntless lair to the zip line from the Sears Tower. (Somewhere, a special effects artist just drooled.) And it's not just about the action. The roles are meaty, and I predict a major internet debate over who should be cast as Four, the dead sexy fighting instructor. Robert Pattinson, don't even THINK about it.

[amazon 0062024035 inline]


About the author

Sarah lives in Austin, TX, where she programs screenings at the Alamo Drafthouse and coordinates events at The Highball, a playground for adults. Tired of feeling like a creepy old lady in the bookstore YA section, she created Forever Young Adult to provide grown-ups with a community where they can gush about young adult literature without shame. In addition to crushing on fictional teenage boys, Sarah enjoys fancy cocktails, dance parties and macaroni and cheese.

Similar Columns

Explore other columns from across the blog.

Book Brawl: Geek Love vs. Water for Elephants

In Book Brawl, two books that are somehow related will get in the ring and fight it out for the coveted honor of being declared literary champion. Two books enter. One book leaves. This month,...

The 10 Best Sci-Fi Books That Should Be Box Office Blockbusters

It seems as if Hollywood is entirely bereft of fresh material. Next year, three different live-action Snow White films will be released in the States. Disney is still terrorizing audiences with t...

Books Without Borders: Life after Liquidation

Though many true book enthusiasts, particularly in the Northwest where locally owned retailers are more common than paperback novels with Fabio on the cover, would never have set foot in a mega-c...

From Silk Purses to Sows’ Ears

Photo via Moviegoers whose taste in cinema consists entirely of keeping up with the Joneses, or if they’re confident in their ignorance, being the Joneses - the middlebrow, the ...

Cliche, the Literary Default

Original Photo by Gerhard Lipold As writers, we’re constantly told to avoid the cliché. MFA programs in particular indoctrinate an almost Pavlovian shock response against it; workshops in...

A Recap Of... The Wicked Universe

Out of Oz marks Gregory Maguire’s fourth and final book in the series beginning with his brilliant, beloved Wicked. Maguire’s Wicked universe is richly complex, politically contentious, and fille...

Reedsy | Editors with Marker (Marketplace Editors)| 2024-05

Submitting your manuscript?

Professional editors help your manuscript stand out for the right reasons.

Reedsy Marketplace UI

1 million authors trust the professionals on Reedsy. Come meet them.