To read this story or to participate in this writing event, you only need a free account.
You can Login with Facebook or create regular account
To find out what this event is about click here

Adrik Kemp's picture

Sea Butterflies

By Adrik Kemp in Teleport Us

How It Rates

Voting for this event has ended
Once you have read this story, please make sure you rate it by clicking the thumbs above. Then take a few minutes to give the author a helpful critique! We're all here for fun but let's try to help each other too.

Description

Post-humans on a destroyed planet trying to fix the wrongs of the past and work out the way of the future and themselves.

Comments

klahol's picture
klahol from Stockholm, Sweden is reading Black Moon March 1, 2013 - 5:46am

Somewhat shakily written at times, some sentences do not really make it. 

The steamy air cloaks my body and whips behind me like the invisible tendrils of an octopus, endless and claustrophobic.

Overall, you have a nice, otherworldly quality to your writing that often works for me. Feels alien in a good way. 

I did get stuck on the butterflies. Took a long while before I understood them somewhat. A lot of your worldbuilding left me a bit confused. 

I did not like that the story just ended. Felt like the first chapter of something longer. 

I would say that there is lots of promise in this story, and you definitely have a cool tone of voice. But for me, this story would need a few revisions for clarity and some work on the worldbuilding. Also, I would have loved a story arc that felt complete. 

 

 

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 1, 2013 - 2:00pm

Hello,

Thank you for reading and commenting. I agree with your points on revision. In terms of the butterflies and the 'first chapter' comment, this is an attempt to work in a world that is intended for a much larger piece so I can see my failing there to properly encapsulate all the elements in one coherent piece.

Adrik

Rob Pearce's picture
Rob Pearce from Cambridge, England is reading Lots of unpublished stuff and short story collections March 1, 2013 - 6:23am

Like klahol I found a fair bit to like here, but much that I didn't.

The prose was shaky in places - it could do with a decent edit and tidy up.

The world building is definitely other-worldly, but for my sensibilities a bit incoherent and incomplete. I found the butterflies too confusing, and the closest I got to an image of them fits a manta-ray far better, so calling them butterflies felt odd.

I felt there was a lack of plot or story arc, especially with the ending, where something finally looked like happening and then suddenly we've skipped completely past it without explanation.

And at the very significant risk of being hypocritical, I couldn't see that this was either utopian or dystopian. Sure it's post... something, but what? Not post-apocalyptic (and that in itself would not be the same as dystopian) because the environmental apocalypse seems to have been averted by universal concensus. And yet that concensus has not created a better world, at least not yet.

So within the constraints of this inadequate scoring system I have to go thumbs down. Sorry.

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 1, 2013 - 2:06pm

Hi,

Thank you for reading and commenting. I mentioned to khalol that this story was an attempt to work within a world created for a much larger piece and that I understand my failing there.

As for utopia/dystopia, again acknowledging that it wasn't clearly enough stated in the work but as none of the main characters are human in the same sense that we understand them, I believe this is dystopian, for the most terrifying future to imagine is one in which we do not even exist.

Adrik

GG_Silverman's picture
GG_Silverman from Seattle March 1, 2013 - 9:05am

Hi Adrik,

I thought your use of language was really unique and at times quite beautiful. And your concept was interesting, though without your synopsis above, I had trouble understanding the dystopian aspects, as they were fairly buried in your story. Like the others, I felt like I was looking for a story arc to follow, to understand what your main character wanted and then to discover whether or not she gets it. 

I can see this story being quite beautiful with more revision. Keep at it!

-g

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 1, 2013 - 1:58pm

Hello,

Thank you for reading and commenting. I will definitely bear your notes in mind when editing but I did want to say how awesome I found it that you considered the main character to be female. When writing, I didn't consider this character to be a particular gender but would have leaned further toward male out of habit so I'm pleased a certain androgyny got through.

Adrik

GG_Silverman's picture
GG_Silverman from Seattle March 1, 2013 - 4:12pm

Cool! Good luck!

Maria Stanislav's picture
Maria Stanislav from the UK is reading ALL the submissions! March 3, 2013 - 8:15am

Everyone's already commented on the issue of the story arc being either insufficient or incomplete, so I won't go there. Stylistically, this piece worked well for me. I enjoyed your world-building, and, being a hopeless first-person-POV addict, I liked your narrator's voice. There are, however, a few moments where you almost break character and start sounding more like the author rather than the narrator.

One is when he/she talks about the work of their maker: "She spends most of her time dealing with the structure of plants and animals and reconfiguring them to survive in the post-human ecosystem of Earth." When the story starts, my first impression of the narrator was one of a fairly primitive creature. As the story went on, that got gradually got dispelled, and we could see that he/she received quite a bit of education from their maker. But not quite enough to come out with the above-quoted sentence in the scope of regular narration, I feel.

The second time is when the narrator quotes the maker's speech about photovoltaic modules. That piece of dialogue is far too long to be remembered word by word, which is what direct quotation implies. Later, you convey their conversation more elegantly -
"She said the humans from before ‘almost destroyed the planet, inside and out but they realised that by leaving the surface to recover, with only a few left behind to tend to the reconstruction-’"

You also slightly overuse the word 'microscopic'. True, it only came up twice in the story, but it's a prominent enough word for a short enough piece, especially when it's easy enough to find a synonym. This may be sheer nitpickery on my behalf, but I feel that the narrator's voice would benefit from more varied word choices, without going too much into technicalities (like I said above, making them sound properly scientific breaks character).

Aside from the POV issues, which, I feel, are minor enough to be fixed in a single round of editing, I really enjoyed your style. I liked your descriptions, I liked the idea of the post-human world left for gradual restoration, the interaction between the maker and the narrator (who, by the way, didn't read as either gender to me; it felt like they were made without a concept of a gender as such). Whatever you intend to do with this piece - incorporate it into a bigger story, or flesh it out to stand on its own - I think that you've got a great world and a great voice to work with.

Cheers!

P.S. Should you have the time and inclination, I'd appreciate it if you dropped by to have a look at my story, A Song For My Brother. I think you and I have some things in common, stylistically.

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 4, 2013 - 2:45am

Thank you for reading and your feedback. I agree on the terms. I had (rather lazily) quoted them to be more like flashbacks but not gone back to smooth them over.

I will definitely be revisiting this story with an aim to expand.

IrishMak's picture
IrishMak from NH March 5, 2013 - 5:44pm

I think the idea has some potential, but as most other commenters have said, it seemed too much like an unfinished piece of a larger whole. And I also see that is what you were working with. The problem for me is that this is a competition for a finished piece and this really isn't. There isn't a lot of conflict, and no real resolution. In the context of the larger piece you imagine, perhaps it would work. Do keep working on it. The basic idea is interesting.

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 18, 2013 - 12:54pm

Thanks for reading and the feedback on the lack of conflict. I will definitely bear that in mind when I revisit this piece! 

Wonder Woman's picture
Wonder Woman from RI is reading 20th Century Ghosts March 15, 2013 - 2:58pm

While I agree with other reviewers that it felt like a snippet of a larger story, I did find myself teleported to this dystopian world while reading it. I enjoyed the descriptions (the multicolored sands of the bay) and the language, and I was surprised to read the main character wasn't female. Gender is never mentioned, but I suppose I automatically thought of a mother somehow since the main character is nurturing & helping other creatures flourish. Interesting! 

I do like the story idea, but wish there was just a bit more to the ending. The story and idea have a lot of potential. Good luck with your revisions! 

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents March 18, 2013 - 12:57pm

Thank you for reading and reviewing. I am again pleased at the gender ambiguity of the main character, but will be reconsidering the ending and this piece as part of a larger piece when I revisit it. I really enjoy the world it is set within so I'm glad you did too.

Adam Jenkins's picture
Adam Jenkins from Bracknell, England is reading RCX Magazine (Issue 1 coming soon) March 28, 2013 - 8:39am

You have a very poetic, almost ethereal quality in your writing that I found really engaging. The narrator (I also assumed female) is very good, as are the glimpses of the Maker. I agree that it is missing a story arc, which does give this an incomplete feeling. Despite this it's a lovely read, and I hope you stick with developing this.

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents April 6, 2013 - 2:18pm

Thank you for reading and your feedback. I'm stuck in this world and couldn't be happier at the moment.

ArlaneEnalra's picture
ArlaneEnalra from Texas is reading Right now I'm editing . . .. March 30, 2013 - 7:31pm

A perfectly balanced creature in a healing world.  The idea of humans engineering someone who is nearly the embodiment  of Gaia is an interesting one.  Very well done!

Adrik Kemp's picture
Adrik Kemp from Sydney is reading Parable of the Talents April 6, 2013 - 2:20pm

Thank you so much for your feedback! I like your Gaia association, very interesting in itself.

sanja.matsis's picture
sanja.matsis April 10, 2013 - 1:51pm

Adrik, I really enjoyed reading your story. It was beautifully written with such visceral description and leaves me very intrigued. It reads as a wonderful tease into a larger story. Well done and keep writing!! Thumbs up!

sanja.matsis's picture
sanja.matsis April 10, 2013 - 1:51pm

Adrik, I really enjoyed reading your story. It was beautifully written with such visceral description and leaves me very intrigued. It reads as a wonderful tease into a larger story. Well done and keep writing!! Thumbs up!