To read this story or to participate in this writing event, you only need a free account.
You can
To find out what this event is about click here
Poor Bastards
How It Rates
Description
Grey is on a mission to save his brother with the aide of an unlikely ally.
*Note* This is the second iteration, altered after reading feedback from the original post.
- Login to post comments
Comments
Hey Wes,
Okay, the title is fitting, but I don't get a sense of what they look like and the sensory input of the opening scene. I know they're bloated, but have their cheeks filled out and what do they smell like? Do they smell like rotting flesh or do they smell Alien?
This paragraph is interesting:
Albeit, do you have to let us know this early in the piece and not later on? There is so much drama in this paragraph that you could exploit in building tension between these characters and the distrust between them.
This is just gorgeous:
This is pretty fantastic too:
I'm a bit hesistant of the term "poor bastard" repeated over and over when referring to the infected. It worked the first time, but the third time I saw it, I no longer feel sorry for the infected, but rather annoyed at the writer for using the term.
What does the body language of these two characters convey to each other? There is so much tension in the above paragraph that you can mine.
The issue that I have with the rest of the story is the distance between the protagonist and the emotional response he would experience in each scene. He tells us alot about what he is going through, don't get me wrong, but the lack of empathy and emotional depth detracts from some very wonderful prose.
I think engaging the emotional part of character will really help in this piece, because it will help the protagonist build up tension in parts of the story where he is alone. He is also teamed up with someone that he does not trust, hence the internal monologue may be paydirt in building up the drama between Grey and Ticks.
Nice work with the memories and Matty, it does create empathy. Although, I think there would be a mixture of emotions between these brothers, especially if Matty does not like Skitchers and Grey is with Ticks
-Chi
First things first, thanks for taking the time to read and for the response.
There's a handful of your criticisms I found interesting, largely because there are pieces of resolutions to your criticisms in the story that I thought would be enough to not cause questions or concerns. Apparently I'll have to play with those pieces more to make them clearer or stronger. Thank you for that.
Everybody wants emotions, but nobody seems to want to speculate as to why he doesn't "appear" to have any. That's another one of the pieces I thought was clear, but apparently isn't. I'll have to look it over.
Thanks again Chi, appreciate the read and the opinions.
Wes
Hey Wes,
Fuckin' A. I understand where you're coming from. Yeah, I get what you're saying with the emotion thing and it's an easy criticism to trot out infront of people just to say "Oh, you didn't do that...nah, nah, nahnah.".
For me, what keeps me flipping pages is this: Being emotionally invested in the character and wondering what is going to happen next. Its that tension and fear for the character that keeps me glued to the page and wondering where all those hours went because I spent all that time reading. Without the emotions in the story, your story lacks bite and after a while the reader will get up and do the laundry.
Even if this guy is burying his emotions under a rockpile of "I'm going to get through this.". There is that internal conflict that bubble up to the surface. There's that survivor guilt that gnaws at him. There's that "Why am I working with a skitcher" internal dialogue that constantly contemplates killing Ticks. There's the fear of his brother being a inflated green mess for the rest of his life. Yes, the character can shove them all down, but especially in the first person, use that to crank up the heat on the protagonist.
Hope this explains my position a little more.
Thanks.
-Chi
First things first, thanks for taking the time to read and for the response.
There's a handful of your criticisms I found interesting, largely because there are pieces of resolutions to your criticisms in the story that I thought would be enough to not cause questions or concerns. Apparently I'll have to play with those pieces more to make them clearer or stronger. Thank you for that.
Everybody wants emotions, but nobody seems to want to speculate as to why he doesn't "appear" to have any. That's another one of the pieces I thought was clear, but apparently isn't. I'll have to look it over.
Thanks again Chi, appreciate the read and the opinions.
Wes
Wes, this is an interesting story. A little scifi-horror thing going on. I dig it. I don't have much to say about it other than I would like a little more description in what the Skitchers look like exactly. I had a hard time imagining it. It wasn't clear if they were humanoid or not. I got the impression they were insect-like but I wasn't really sure. Also there is a point when you introduce Ticks that you say "we" were going to kill him. Not sure who the "we" are. Grey and his brother or other humans out in the world? Overall a cool story.
Dude. DUUUUDE. I read the original draft you posted on here and this one is light years better! I wish I had known sooner that you had posted a new draft so I could gush sooner. Wow. I loooove this story now and the last line near killed me. Really well done, great editing job and I can only say good things about this. Nice job!!!
I liked this, a nice little contained story that hinted at a much wider world but without seeming like it was overly condensed. The human farming aspect is not an original idea, but it does not feel derivitive here. I was torn while reading it between hoping for a happy ending of sorts, and half expecting Grey to be caught and hooked up himself, all the time knowing exactly what was happening to him. What I liked about your ending is the ambiguity as to whether or not they are moving on to a better situation. Waking them up during feeding is nicely nasty, but it does take away a little from that ambiguity. I can understand other commenters wanting to see more of the Skitchers, but that wasn't a problem for me. Calling the friendly one Ticks, and the way you describe them moving, made them very insect-like for me. Not describing them fully just meant I could picture them as I wanted to. Good story!
Huh! I read this a long while back, I know I did! Apparently, I didn't comment on it then. :( I noticed you stripped out the parts about what was going on inside the DreamNet. The story does seem to flow better without the context switches between reality and the dream. You might add a bit about what the dream is like.
Excellent Work!