I've heard some of the big ones: leave the piece alone until you come back to it reading like a stranger, cut words and phrases that don't pull their weight, stuff like that. I'm trying to figure out to make bigger changes in this long short story from over a year ago. With my fresh eyes and all I can see prose problems I couldn't, make a lot of the dialogue better, but I'm still looking to cut this monster down from around 9,500 words to closer to 8. More if I can swing it. I'm thinking I might start trying to send it out to mags, but I want to tighten it up first. How do you guys go about the second draft?
I'd start by reading it out loud, and anywhere you stumble, or it doesn't quite flow very well, cut it, or change it so that it does.
Try to be good, not different.
I feel like editing as you go will slow you down too much and you'll never really get anywhere with your story. That's why it's good to write with pen and paper, there's no backspace key. For me, writing flows better when it's almost stream of conscious writing. Then put it away for however long you think you need and then open it and edit it minimally. Usually sheering off words here and there is all it needs. And yes, reading it out loud. I never thought that was true until I read a story at an open mic that I'd written years ago and knew and loved and all of a sudden, I saw a sentence or two that had weird syntax and needed to be fixed.
Re-read, re-read, re-read, re-read, re-read. Be a total narcissist and just keep at it. All those unnecessary words and phrases will start popping up.
No. Add Stop over thinking to the list.
I mean that put your focus on good writing, not orginal writing.
Rewrite from the beginning?
Cut a subplot or unnecessary plot point?
If it's over 9K words, it's probably more than one scene. Do you need all of them? Do you need all of the paragraphs or could you cut chunks out without harming the reader's understanding? etc.
Unless you look broader than sentence by sentence, you'll never cut much.
I think there is a sweet spot for short stories from 2k to 5k words, and I hate it when I write long short stories (or novelettes, as your story is now). Cuts down on the possible markets.
Novelette is 7500 to 15000 words (or 17,500 for speculative fiction). But those are just definitions. Some markets have maximum of 5K or 7K or 10K.
Hi Redd,
Did you have any luck cutting down your story to the desired length?
I never think about it going to be a novel when I write it. I'm in such a wakeful sleep mode it just kind if flows.
That moment when you are fully awake and still seeing your PTSD nightmares unfold.
I edit using eight most common themes from my life.