Seen it? What did you think? Post about it here. Spoilers are to be expected here.
I loved it.
Loved it too!
I have some complaints, sure, which I'll flesh out in an upcoming article, but my criticisms have a lot to do with the treatment of Mike. They fucked up there, I thought.
Bev and Richie and, of course, Pennywise were the standouts.
Really excellent movie.
Obviously the book's better, yes.
I'll be honest except for The Rock fight and the depiction of Pennywise I was generally disappointed. I felt like they gave Bev too much screen time at the expense of other characters and it just seems like if they're going to have a two-and-a-half-hour movie about the first half of the book everyone could have been a little more developed.
Pretty much always the book is better. Sometimes I think you have to view movies as separate entities to their original source. The shining for example: the book is on another level but the movie is great in it's own right (likewise Misery, Coraline, Fight club etc) Of course there are plenty of movies from books that get it so wrong. In my experience it helps if you haven't just read the book before you watch the movie. I read IT when I was thirteen so there are plenty of things I have forgotten. Sure there were moments that could have been different (Bev didn't get kidnapped in the book, right?) but it's a very fun version of the book. I enjoyed the humour, the brutality, the darkness and the eighties nostalgia.
I think 80s nostalgia is a general trend at the moment, not just in the horror genre, maybe it's just that the adults who were 80s kids are now the prime age for dreaming about the past (and spending money on it) and the next generation are being re-served modern versions of eighties classics (Flatliners...why?!?)
Regarding your comment about Stan's lack of screen time; it makes me wonder if this is because of his fate, in that I guess he has a smaller part to play in part two, although contradictory imo you would think they would want to show just how much the events traumatized him and scared him to justify his reaction.
Also I had originally wondered if the decision to make Ben the historian rather than Mike, meant that it would be Ben who stayed in Derry as librarian. However from the interview I read yesterday it sounds like Mike is still going to be the one who stays, only he's also going to be quite "messed up" in the future - a junkie in fact. What do you guys think to that change?